Centre Write
Progressive Conscience Autumn 2013
Progressive Conscience Autumn 2013

Progressive Conscience Autumn 2013

Welcome to our quarterly magazine, The Progressive Conscience. Feel free to browse the articles below, or download a .pdf of the magazine here.

Justin Timberlake brought sexy back. Sir Thomas Wyatt brought sonnets back. As of the Labour Party conference, Ed Miliband is ‘bringing socialism back’. For the third time, perhaps, it’s good news for Tories. But is he? George W Bush’s economic advisor, David Frum, argues in his interview with The Progressive Conscience that conservatives in the modern political climate can no longer take for granted that parties of the left, whether in the UK or the US, are unacceptable to people of enterprise. Sure, it’s a relief for the Conservatives when the separate elements within our party can unite against something…
The man behind the phrase ‘Axis of Evil’ talks to Kate Maltby about his regrets over Iraq and his warnings for David Cameron . This is an edited transcript of a two-hour conversation. KM: How does modernisation differ from centrism? Every modern democracy has a party that speaks enthusiastically for the public sector. And every democracy needs a party that speaks enthusiastically for the private sector. In Britain that party is the Conservatives. In the United States that party is the Republicans. Conservative modernisers are clearly on the right of that dividing line. To champion enterprise effectively we have to…
Each issue, The Progressive Conscience asks a retired politician to confess their greatest political regret. This edition Douglas Hurd talks of his failure to save the Royal Yacht The Royal Yacht Britannia has now come to rest in the harbour at Leith, outside Edinburgh. Tourists are encouraged to visit and I have been to see the suite which my wife and I used to occupy on board. Suite is rather a grand name for two small cabins, one of which was organised as an office, with a third room alongside for a private secretary. The Britannia has been refurbished since…
Louise Mensch writes from New York on what she’s heard about Hillary and why Cameron should keep faith with Chris Christie. Follow Louise on Twitter. It’s strange watching the parallels develop. After the disaster of the McCain-Palin campaign (think Hague as leader), the GOP at least was respectable under Romney (think Michael Howard). But they are now where Howard was – no hope of victory, with no light in sight down a long, dark tunnel and the need for major reform. The GOP needs to learn the lessons of Nate Silver and actually read the polls. The Romney campaign was…
Each issue, a Conservative MP tells us why they’re part of the Bright Blue family. This issue, Laura Sandys , MP for South Thanet, tells us why she’s a Bright Blue parliamentary supporter Politics is a reflection of the public. As the public are dynamic and innovative our politics must be too. Bright Blue is a movement that is constantly challenging and contesting our thinking, our actions and our ambitions, ensuring that the shadow of complacency can never darken our doors. I am thrilled to be part of the Bright Blue family, looking optimistically at the future of our party…
Sunder Katwala looks ahead to one of the big questions of 2014 Englishness has now overtaken being British as the primary official identity in England. In the 2011 census, 69% of people said they were English, and only 29% chose British. That dramatic statistic exaggerates the shift. Few ticked two boxes on their census form, but most still say both identities matter. What has changed is the realisation that they are not the same thing. Scotland’s historic independence referendum on September 18th 2014 will accelerate this. Few in England outside the political class have yet noticed this is happening. By…
Alex Massie explains why flirting with UKIP could cost the Conservatives more than they think Like most normal people I had never heard of Godfrey Bloom until recently. I don’t suppose many of his notional constituents in Yorkshire and Northern Lincolnshire could name their Member of the European Parliament either. The wages of political obscurity are paid in public indifference. Even now I fancy even politically-aware voters would be hard pressed to name Mr Bloom. If he is remembered at all he is surely only known as the Bongo Bongo guy. Or, most lately, the slut guy. Ah yes, your…
For this issue’s window on centre-right politics around the world, Oliver Cooper takes a look at the youthful centre-right in Europe “Advance Australia, fair!” went the cry from Conservatives at the victory of Tony Abbott’s Liberals in September. For the first time in 33 years, there are centre-right Prime Ministers in Britain, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand. But it’s not just in the Anglosphere where the centre-right is on the rise. Across the EU, only 8 countries out of 28 are led by socialist leaders. Even in the Nordic countries – that bastion of the left – only one socialist…
Each issue of The Progressive Conscience , a Fleet Street editor looks at the uses and abuses of political terminology. Stephen Pollard explores the meaning of the word ‘neocon’ It’s time once again for that oh-so-fun game. It’s the perennial favourite that requires not a moment’s thought. Yes, it’s time for Neocon Bingo. And this time the focus is Syria. You win a point for each mention of the word ‘neocon’. As for a prize: well, there isn’t one really. Perhaps a dose of depression at the inability of so many people to engage any part of their brain before…
Penny Mordaunt MP draws on her American experience to ask if the Special Relationship has been damaged by the vote on Syria The short and obvious answer is ‘no’. The relationship enjoyed by Britain and America is not between a president and a prime minister, or a congress and a parliament, but between two peoples. Certainly the course of that relationship is eased when there is personal and political accord between the nations’ leaders, but it is not contingent on the avoidance of any divergence in policy. Ed Miliband was right about that, but I suspect that I am right…
Daniel Finkelstein tells Bright Blue why Martin Luther King is a model for modernising Conservatives on both sides of the Atlantic The crowd was tired, a little restless, maybe even a tiny bit bored and Martin Luther King Jr did something he hadn’t planned to. He used his familiar riff about having a dream. His aides sighed, fed up to hear all that old stuff again, unaware until later that they were hearing one of the greatest political speeches of the last century. They were also present at a seminal moment in American politics. Fifty years ago in Britain, Harold…
Iain Martin on why economists should look to Teddy Roosevelt’s attack on crony capitalism rather than FDR’s spending impetus When the financial crisis hit and the economy went into a tail-spin, there was briefly a renewed interest in several giants of the 20th century whose reputations were forged in the aftermath of the economic disaster of the early 1930s. After our own financial crisis and sustained slump, some on the centre-left argued that Keynes had all the answers. Others pointed to FDR, citing him as the President who had shown how to deliver a stimulus, in the the form of…
One of America’s leading bloggers, James Poulos argues that the GOP needs to take a class in anthropology to find its guiding spirit Although Barack Obama has finally begun to learn for himself just how disappointing a second term can be, Republicans have little reason to celebrate. They have not recovered from the trauma of the Bush years. The party’s shell-shocked effort to reboot, rebrand, and reform its way out from under W’s legacy ranks as one of the great bores of American politics. The prevailing fear is the GOP suffers from a wonk gap, or a data gap, or…
Pascal-Emmanuel Gobry on why addressing inequality with family policy is the biggest problem for the American Right and the best Cameroon idea that Cameron dropped The central challenge of political economy in the rich world since the Industrial Revolution has been to make free-market capitalism politically sustainable. Free markets create wealth and prosperity. But they also create churn and disruption, big winners yet also big losers, and thus undermine their own political sustainability, as populations see their way of life disrupted and rebel against the whole idea. The best way we’ve found so far to thread the needle has been…
Will Tanner takes a look at the Republicans who are applying fiscal responsibility to America’s unsustainable prison population – and calls on Tories to copy them America has long been the poster child for lock ‘em up justice. The US imprisons more people in both proportionate and absolute terms than any country on Earth. The Land of the Free holds 5% of the world’s population and 25% of its prisoners. Decades of prison-happy policies at both state and federal level made jail the default rather than the last resort: between 1990 and 2005 the prison population doubled even as crime…
Bright Blue has been building relationships with think tanks across the pond. Over these pages, four experts tell us what Tory policy can learn from their research Once upon a time, before George W. Bush, before George H.W. Bush, there was Vannevar Bush. Roosevelt’s wartime science advisor, Bush, V., helped shape not just American but global approaches to the public funding of science. His 1945 report Science, The Endless Frontier, remains relevant and readable. Read it antiphonally with his somewhat unnerving prophecy in Atlantic of the World Wide Web – as a technology evolved from microfiche. As Americans are too…
Bright Blue has been building relationships with think tanks across the pond. Over these pages, four experts tell us what Tory policy can learn from their research The day after the House of Commons voted against military involvement in Syria, The Sun front cover splashed with a “death notice” for the Special Relationship. “The funeral will be held at the French Embassy... no flowers please.” Depending on one’s view, the recent Commons vote was either a victory for common sense or a tragedy for Britain’s role in the world. Either way it is not the end, or even the beginning…
Bright Blue has been building relationships with think tanks across the pond. Over these pages, four experts tell us what Tory policy can learn from their research American conservatives have always been of two minds about immigration. The first instinct extols the virtues and benefits of immigration – a process that makes America wealthier and more culturally prosperous, as well as being consistent with our old historical roots. The second is concerned that immigrants make America less American – less prosperous, less free, and less culturally familiar. In line with the second instinct, Republicans are typically more opposed to immigration…
Bright Blue has been building relationships with think tanks across the pond. Over these pages, four experts tell us what Tory policy can learn from their research Several months ago, I was grateful for the opportunity to deliver a major address in Stamford, Connecticut, just outside New York City, on the enormous consequence of the current lack of civility in politics and its impact on consensus-building and problem-solving. My remarks were part of a speaker series exploring the importance of civility in multiple spheres of American life. It was 5:30 in the afternoon, at a public library, and close to…
Peter Hoskin on his favourite political film Sorry to spoil it for you, but at the end of this year’s White House Down Jamie Foxx’s President Sawyer isn’t actually shot dead – you’re just made to think he is. What saves his life is an old pocket-watch inscribed to Abraham Lincoln from his wife Mary Todd, which stops the bullet. “Abe took a second bullet for me,” deadpans Sawyer as he raises himself from the ground. For that line, and even worse infractions against taste, you wish Abe hadn’t bothered. Thankfully, cinema hasn’t always treated Lincoln so cheaply. Directors from…
Jesse Norman MP tells Bright Blue why his hero Edmund Burke would have been cautious about Lords Reform and the modernising temper As last year’s fiscal cliff crisis reminded us, American politics has rarely been more polarised than it is today. Many Democrats rage with disappointment at a President for whom they had cherished wildly unrealistic hopes; while the Republican party is pulled ever further apart by a toxic combination of personal rivalry and ideological zeal. The result is rancour, legislative gridlock and fragmentation. And temporarily at least, American conservatism seems to have all but lost its way. Just as…
Brooks Newmark, the American-born MP and Vice-President of the Harvard Alumni Association, tells British students to head to the Ivy League I was lucky enough to have had the opportunity to attend both Harvard and Oxford, so I feel well placed to compare and understand the best of America and Britain’s respective education systems. Whilst many tertiary level academic institutions in both countries offer exceptionally high standards of education, American universities offer that little bit more at undergraduate level by encouraging students to study a wide range of subjects, and offering the flexibility to change the core subject of your…

Latest from Twitter